Find Doctors and Dentists Near You
The location you tried did not return a result. Please enter a valid 5-digit Zip Code.

You can also search by physician, practice, or hospital name

Kaley Puzynski

Dr. Kaley Brooke Puzynski, PA

Virtual Visit Available


About Kaley Puzynski The journey into health care for Kaley Puzynski, PA-C, was inspired by the remarkable influences of her parents. Drawing from her mother’s dedication as an Emergency Room Nurse and her father’s craftsmanship as a custom home builder, Kaley found her calling in blending caregiving with precision. Kaley’s experience gives her an expertise in Orthopedic Trauma Surgery and Plastics and Oncology Reconstructive surgery as a Certified Physician Assistant. Kaley earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Sports Medicine from the University of North Florida, and later completed her Master of Physician Assistant Studies from Nova Southeastern University, both located in Jacksonville, FL. In her role within Neurosurgery, Kaley works under the supervision of licensed physicians to provide medical care to patients. She conducts physical exams, diagnoses and treats illnesses, orders and interprets tests, assists in surgeries, prescribes medications, and provides patient education and counseling. Her mission extends beyond medical interventions – Kaley is committed to making health care more accessible and efficient, focusing on compassionate, patient-centered care. “I prioritize compassionate and patient-centered care,” Kaley says. “Establishing open communication, building trust, and tailoring treatment plans to individual needs are at the core of my practice.” Recognizing the uniqueness of each patient, she approaches her work with unwavering respect and a commitment to their well-being. In her own words… Who is or was the most influential people/role models in your life?  Dr. Stephen Lucie What was your first job growing up? What do you remember about it?  I worked as an event planner for a local company. What is your favorite food? Movie?  Favorite foods: Tacos      Favorite movie: Disney’s Moana What was your best/worst subjects in school growing up?  Best: Anatomy; Worst: Math If you could sit down to dinner with anyone (alive or deceased) who would it be and why?  I would sit down to dinner with my grandma before her onset of dementia. I would love to get that time back with her. What are your hobbies, interests and what are you passionate about?  I have a deep passion for international travel, having explored diverse destinations such as Australia, Japan, Ireland, Iceland and many others! I have a curiosity for diverse cultures and an appreciation for global experiences. I also embrace a holistic approach to health and wellness through an active lifestyle and engage in various physical activities, including running, Scuba diving, and Fitness Training, to name a few. Do you have pets?  Yes, I have two golden doodles, Remi and Ruger. What is something most people don’t know about you?  My husband and I do tactical shooting training in our spare time.
View more


Explains conditions and treatments
Takes time to answer my questions
Provides follow-up as needed

Based on patient feedback.


Dr. Puzynski's Rating
Patient Perspective
5.0 Explains conditions and treatments
5.0 Takes time to answer my questions
5.0 Provides follow-up as needed
Office Rating
Showing ratings for:
500 Arcade Ave Ste 200, Elkhart, IN, 46514
n/a Average office wait time
n/a Office cleanliness
n/a Courteous staff
n/a Scheduling flexibility
500 Arcade Ave Ste 200
Elkhart, IN, 46514
Showing 1-1 of 1 review
  • August 20, 2021


500 Arcade Ave Ste 200
Elkhart, IN, 46514
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mon8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri8:00 am - 4:00 pm
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted


  • neurogenic claudication
  • non ruptured cerebral aneurysm
  • normal pressure hydrocephalus
  • oligodendroglioma
  • pinched nerve
  • pituitary adenoma
  • pituitary cancer
  • pituitary tumor
  • skull base tumor
  • skull fracture
  • spinal abscess
  • spinal cord compression
  • spinal cord tumors
  • spinal schwannoma
  • spinal stenosis
  • spine fracture
  • spine injury
  • spine mass
  • spine tumor
  • spondylosis with myelopathy
  • subdural hematoma
  • thoracic spinal stenosis
  • thoracic spine fracture
  • thoracic spine injury
  • thoracic spine mass
  • thoracic spine tumor
  • vascular brain tumors
  • vascular malformations of the brain
  • venous malformation brain
  • vertebral fracture


  • Neurosurgery


  • Neurosurgery


Please verify insurance information directly with your doctor's office as it may change frequently.
  • Aetna Medicare Advantage (Via CHA ACO LLC)
  • Ambetter Marketplace (MHS)
  • Anthem BCBS
  • Anthem Healthy Indiana Plan (HIP)
  • Anthem Medicaid (HHW HCC)
  • Anthem Medicare Advantage
  • CareSource Marketplace
  • CareSource Medicaid (HHW)
  • CareSource Medicaid (HIP)
  • CHA ACO LLC dba Beacon ACO
  • Cigna
  • Community Health Alliance (CHA Aetna PHP Freedom First Health)
  • Encore
  • Humana
  • Humana Medicare Advantage
  • Managed Health Services Healthly Indiana Plan (MHS HIP)
  • Managed Health Services Medicaid (MHS HCC)
  • Managed Health Services Medicaid (MHS HHW)
  • Mdwise Excel Healthy Indiana Plan (HIP)
  • Mdwise Excel Medicaid (HHW)
  • Medicaid Indiana FFS
  • Medicaid Michigan FFS
  • Medicare FFS
  • Sagamore
  • Signature Care / Parkview
  • Tricare East Humana Military
  • UnitedHealthcare (UHC)
  • UnitedHealthcare Medicaid (HCC)
  • UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage (UHC)
  • VA CCN Optum UHC



Data Transparency and Trust: Understanding WebMD Doctor Listings and Reviews

We know that finding the right doctor or provider is important to your health. That’s why we want to ensure you have confidence in the provider profiles and listings you see on WebMD Care. Our provider data is sourced from the physicians themselves as well as publicly available databases. Any doctor or provider who claims their profile by verifying themselves can update their information and provide additional data on their specialties, education, accepted insurances, conditions they treat, and procedures they perform.

All the physician and provider reviews on WebMD Care are provided by users just like you. Knowing these reviews provide insight into how other patients feel about a doctor, we maintain internal policies and protocols to ensure the quality and accuracy of all reviews. Providers are not able to remove or modify reviews on their own. Reviews can only be removed after an internal review by our customer service team.

We value your input and encourage you to reach out to our support team if you encounter any issues.