Find Doctors and Dentists Near You
The location you tried did not return a result. Please enter a valid 5-digit Zip Code.

You can also search by physician, practice, or hospital name

TR

Dr. Tobi J. Reidy, DO

Colorectal SurgerySurgeryOther Specialty

OVERVIEW

Dr. Reidy graduated from the Nova Southeastern University College of Osteopathic in 2005. She works in Indianapolis, IN and 4 other locations and specializes in Colorectal Surgery, Surgery and Other Specialty. Dr. Reidy is affiliated with Community Health Network South Campus.

PATIENT'S PERSPECTIVE

Explains conditions and treatments
Takes time to answer my questions

Based on patient feedback. Read the reviews

RATINGS AND REVIEWS

Dr. Reidy's Rating
8 Ratings with 4 Reviews
Patient Perspective
4.0 Explains conditions and treatments
4.0 Takes time to answer my questions
3.5 Provides follow-up as needed
Office Rating
Showing ratings for:
5255 E Stop 11 Rd Ste 250, Indianapolis, IN, 46237
n/a Average office wait time
3.0 Office cleanliness
2.0 Courteous staff
1.0 Scheduling flexibility
Franciscan Physician Network
5255 E Stop 11 Rd Ste 250
Indianapolis, IN, 46237
4 REVIEWS
Showing 1-4 of 4 reviews
"Dr. Reidy is a total liar. Do NOT trust her with your care. Also, her Indianapolis facility is total ghetto and dirty and the staff there are quite rude and not friendly at all. She had been my surgeon since 2015 to treat anal lesions. I was pleased with her initially, but in recent years, she told me inaccurate and very confusing information, sometimes changing her story from what she told me prior. I continued to see her because I liked her overall. However, after surgery with her last week, I will never let her touch me again. Immediately after my surgery, I told a nurse I had to pee really badly (they were pumping me full of IV liquids beforehand so I could do a pregnancy test and I was never allowed to use the bathroom and a different nurse just had me sign a pregnancy waiver instead). The nurse said she would bring a bedpan. Never did. I then told the anesthesiologist the same thing and she ignored it. Then Dr. Reidy came in and I told her the same thing and so did my boyfriend. ...
She told me to just pee in the bed!!! I did not. I complained about this and many other things her staff did that were a total mess...everything from scheduling mistakes to never giving me the correct prep instructions despite me asking 3 times and multiple people...and she wrote me a MyChart message completely lying about me and my boyfriend, gaslighting us and telling us reality did not actually happen. Dr. Reidy proceeded to lie and say she never told me to pee the bed. Then she said I actually told her I had to poop and used PROFANITY to do so! THIS NEVER, EVER HAPPENED. I don't even speak that way and I only ever had to pee. I eventually was allowed to go pee after she finished going over a ton of info with me and my boyfriend and a nurse came back in and then had to go again 10 or 15 minutes later. My bladder was so full I was in pain. I cannot believe a surgeon would make up an insane lie about me to hide her own terrible patient care. She claimed I told her I had to "shit" and did so "comically. I told her she was lying and will be filing a formal complaint. She also does not know very basic information about ulcerative colitis. Many times she told me totally inaccurate basic information. Definitely never even consider ever having her do any type of surgery for UC such as a jpouch on you. She is not qualified for that and made up lies about a simple anal condyloma removal procedure. She also never made sense when explaining HPV types, told me conflicting things many times, and apparently didn't do the anal swab correctly on me because my results said I didn't even have HPV but we knew I did from all my office visits literally showing it. If I believed her, I would've thought I was cured from that. "
Read more
  • September 18, 2022
"I have been her patient since 2017. She is truly an amazing doctor!! World class care! Compassion, understanding of your concerns and fears! Explains everything thoroughly in "clear terms". Makes you feel comfortable in some very uncomfortable situations!! Would be 10 STARS if that was possible!!"
  • January 15, 2022
"My mom went to the ER with diverticulitis, she was in torturous pain for 12 hours screaming. Dr Toby Reidy was supposed to perform surgery but she was double-booked and did not finish on time so my mom's intestines exploded, twice. It doesn’t say this in the records she reported that my mom was immediately taken to surgery after signing consent, which is false. She told my mom her first surgery went over. My dad ran into the hallway for help crying, and it was a ghost town, my mom was left there to die. Dr Reidy had to open her up again because mom got sepsis. She had to have her bowels reconstructed, it wasn’t done correctly. The nurse kept sticking her over and over again, she couldn’t get the IV. Mom caught an infection in the hospital, had to have a tent around her and everyone had to be dressed in PPE, head-to-toe. Board of Health had to intervene. She had to spend 20 days in the hospital and 30 in a nursing home with a colostomy. We have had nightmares bc of this, this has affected ...
our trust in the medical community. Is this how you treat seniors? Why did you not call backup, knowing the condition that my mom was in? "
Read more
  • December 13, 2021
"She performed an extensive surgery on my mother that included a colostomy. Later, complications developed from the surgery which interfered with her abdomen included severe pain, vomiting and my mother was unable to eat. She had developed a huge hernia which was pressing on veins and arteries. After numerous attempts to call and speak with someone in her office, we were told that they would notify Dr. Reidy and she would contact us.... called twice, spoke with Andrea and Kelly and we NEVER received a phone call back. We ended up taking my mother to the hospital. We were notified by three doctors to contact Dr. Reidy immediately and have her review the new cat scan to see what we should do, my mother needed another surgery. We called Dr. Reidys office and started to tell the nurse what the doctors at the hospital wanted us to notify Dr. Reidy about and the nurse interrupted and told us again that they would turn it over to Dr. Reidy ASAP. Never heard a thing once again. We also needed to ...
have my mother measured for a colostomy belt and called numerous times about this, to no avail, they never responded. We had to find another doctor to review my mothers case and repair the colostomy hernia. Dr. Reidys office took no responsibility in assisting my mother after the surgery. "
Read more
  • March 4, 2021

LOCATIONS

Franciscan Physician Network Indiana Colon And Rectal Specialists
5255 E Stop 11 Rd Ste 250
Indianapolis, IN, 46237
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mon8:30 am - 5:00 pm
Tue8:30 am - 5:00 pm
Wed8:30 am - 5:00 pm
Thu8:30 am - 5:00 pm
Fri8:30 am - 5:00 pm
SatClosed
SunClosed
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
5255 E Stop 11 Rd Ste 100
Indianapolis, IN, 46237
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mon7:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue7:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed7:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu7:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri7:00 am - 5:00 pm
SatClosed
SunClosed
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Franciscan Physician Network Indiana Colon And Rectal Specialists
1215 Hadley Rd Ste 201
Mooresville, IN, 46158
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mon8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri8:00 am - 5:00 pm
SatClosed
SunClosed
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicare Accepted
  • Medicaid Accepted
Franciscan Health Mooresville
1201 Hadley Rd
Mooresville, IN, 46158
Mon8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu8:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri8:00 am - 5:00 pm
SatClosed
SunClosed
8111 S Emerson Ave
Indianapolis, IN, 46237

EDUCATION AND TRAINING

Medical School
Nova Southeastern University College Of Osteopathic
Graduated 2005

INSURANCE PLANS ACCEPTED  (46)

Please verify insurance information directly with your doctor's office as it may change frequently.
  • First Health PPO
  • UHC Choice Plus POS
  • UHC Navigate POS
  • PHCS PPO
  • Aetna Signature Administrators PPO
  • Multiplan PPO
  • Humana ChoiceCare Network PPO
  • CIGNA PPO
  • Aetna Choice POS II
  • Anthem Blue Access PPO
  • Sagamore Plus
  • Humana Choice POS
  • Anthem Blue Preferred HMO
  • Aetna Managed Choice POS Open Access
  • Encore Health Network
  • UHC Options PPO
  • CIGNA Open Access Plus
  • SIHO Network
  • CIGNA HMO
  • BCBS IL PPO
  • MDWise Mrktplace
  • UHC Navigate HMO
  • Ambetter from MHS HIX
  • BCBS Blue Card PPO
  • Aetna HMO
  • Anthem Blue Preferred Plus POS
  • Ambetter Superior Health Plan
  • Aexcel PPO
  • HealthSync HMO - IN
  • HealthSync Options POS
  • HealthSync PPO - IN
  • MEDICA CHOICE WITH UNITEDHEALTHC
  • UHC NAVIGATE PLUS POS
  • CareSource Indiana
  • UHC Nexus Open Access
  • Aetna Elect Choice EPO Open Access
  • Aetna Innovation Health Aetna Premier Care Network Plus
  • Aetna Open Choice PPO
  • Ambetter IN
  • Anthem HealthSync HMO - IN
  • Anthem HealthSync Options POS
  • Anthem HealthSync PPO - IN
  • BCBSA Blue Card High Performance Network
  • Humana / ChoiceCare Network PPO
  • Humana/ChoiceCare+ Network PPO
  • Medica Choice With UHC
View more

SIMILAR PROVIDERS

Data Transparency and Trust: Understanding WebMD Doctor Listings and Reviews

We know that finding the right doctor or provider is important to your health. That’s why we want to ensure you have confidence in the provider profiles and listings you see on WebMD Care. Our provider data is sourced from the physicians themselves as well as publicly available databases. Any doctor or provider who claims their profile by verifying themselves can update their information and provide additional data on their specialties, education, accepted insurances, conditions they treat, and procedures they perform.

All the physician and provider reviews on WebMD Care are provided by users just like you. Knowing these reviews provide insight into how other patients feel about a doctor, we maintain internal policies and protocols to ensure the quality and accuracy of all reviews. Providers are not able to remove or modify reviews on their own. Reviews can only be removed after an internal review by our customer service team.

We value your input and encourage you to reach out to our support team if you encounter any issues.