Find Doctors and Dentists Near You
The location you tried did not return a result. Please enter a valid 5-digit Zip Code.

You can also search by physician, practice, or hospital name

CC

Dr. Carolyn May Castiglia, DO

Family MedicineOsteopathic Medicine

OVERVIEW

Dr. Castiglia graduated from the New York Institute of Technology College of Osteopathic Medicine in 1996. She works in Island Park, NY and 1 other location and specializes in Family Medicine and Osteopathic Medicine. Dr. Castiglia is affiliated with South Nassau Communities Hospital.

PATIENT'S PERSPECTIVE

Explains conditions and treatments
Takes time to answer my questions
Provides follow-up as needed

Based on patient feedback. Read the reviews

RATINGS AND REVIEWS

Dr. Castiglia's Rating
42 Ratings with 2 Reviews
Patient Perspective
4.0 Explains conditions and treatments
4.5 Takes time to answer my questions
4.5 Provides follow-up as needed
Office Rating
Showing ratings for:
3 California Pl S, Island Park, NY, 11558
n/a Average office wait time
2.0 Office cleanliness
3.0 Courteous staff
3.0 Scheduling flexibility
South Island Family Medical Llc
3 California Pl S
Island Park, NY, 11558
2 REVIEWS
Showing 1-2 of 2 reviews
"I had the worst experience being dropped as a patient for inactivity and then told she’s not taking new patients after being with her for over 12 years!! Her office staff is horrific and never answer the phones and so rude. The best dr in her practice Dr Bedell left and he was able to take me in his new practice plus got an appt right away. Don’t bother with her, horrific staff or outdated & tiny office"
  • December 7, 2022
"Garbage person to person care. I concur with all the other reviewers here. Before you find my criticism too harsh I want to say that the people you hire directly represent you so yes Dr. Castiglia is responsible for her employees actions as well as the procedural guidelines that are set up in her office. I was accepted as a patient and came in for a normal check up. Almost three years had elapsed. I felt good and had no health issues. Work schedule had prevented me from coming in for a check up since. Recently I had developed a concerning medical issue. I called her office only to find out that I had been dropped as I patient because I did not give them enough business. Frankly just wanted to explain my situation to her. I was then told by the secretary that I was not considered one of her patients any more and she would not be able to speak to me. Just want to speak to her for 5 minutes when she got a chance or even the next day or two. I was told to go to urgent care if it was that ...
serious. The secretaries attitude was cringe worthy. She would say things like you said that all ready, you said that all ready. I was 100% polite and cordial until the end I could not take her flippant attitude any more.. If they dropped me as a patient it would have been courteous to send me a letter saying so this way i could have started looking for someone else and not be blind sided by this under less then ideal circumstances :( "
Read more
  • May 30, 2021

LOCATIONS

3 California Pl S
Island Park, NY, 11558
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mon9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Tue9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Wed9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Thu9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Fri9:00 am - 5:00 pm
Sat9:00 am - 1:00 pm
SunClosed
  • Accepting New Patients
  • Medicaid Accepted
Mount Sinai South Nassau
1 Healthy Way
Oceanside, NY, 11572

CONDITIONS TREATED

View more

PROCEDURES PERFORMED

EDUCATION AND TRAINING

Medical School
New York Institute Of Technology College Of Osteopathic Medicine
Graduated 1996

INSURANCE PLANS ACCEPTED  (107)

Please verify insurance information directly with your doctor's office as it may change frequently.
  • MVP Preferred PPO
  • Empire Prism EPO Blue Priority
  • UHC Navigate HMO
  • Oscar Insurance NY
  • Oxford Metro
  • Empire HMO Bronze Individual via Exchange
  • Aetna HMO
  • Fidelis Care NY State of Health HBX
  • Aetna Signature Administrators PPO
  • UHC Choice Plus POS
  • PHCS PPO
  • Healthfirst NY HMO ABCD
  • UHC Options PPO
  • First Health PPO
  • Oxford Liberty
  • Empire PPO
  • CDPHP PPO
  • Humana Choice POS
  • Empire HMO
  • BCBS Blue Card PPO
  • UHC Compass HMO
  • Oxford Freedom
  • CIGNA PPO
  • Aetna Choice POS II
  • CIGNA Open Access Plus
  • Aetna Elect Choice EPO
  • CDPHP New York State of Health - Small Business
  • BCBS MA Blue Care Elect PPO
  • UHC Navigate POS
  • Aetna NYC Community Plan
  • Multiplan PPO
  • Aetna Managed Choice POS Open Access
  • Humana ChoiceCare Network PPO
  • CIGNA HMO
  • Aetna Select
  • Aexcel PPO
  • PPO
  • BluePPO HSA
  • Empire Blue Priority NY
  • Fidelis Care Essential Plan
  • Fidelis Mrktplace
  • Green Leaf Plans
  • HIP Prime HMO
  • Leaf Premier Plans
  • MEDICA CHOICE WITH UNITEDHEALTHC
  • MVP EPO/PPO
  • MVP Liberty EPO/PPO
  • Oscar Circle
  • Oscar Circle Plus
  • Oxford Garden State
  • PPO 6000 Series
  • Savings Plus of Metro NY
  • UHC NAVIGATE PLUS POS
  • Excellus BCBS CNY Preferred Gold - Tier 1
  • Excellus BCBS SimplyBlue/SimplyBlue Plus
  • UHC Nexus Open Access
  • Aetna Elect Choice EPO Open Access
  • Aetna Innovation Health Aetna Premier Care Network Plus
  • Aetna Open Choice PPO
  • Aetna Premier Care Network APCN Choice POS II OAMC
  • Aetna Savings Plus of Metro NY
  • BCBS WNY PPO
  • BCBSA Blue Card High Performance Network
  • BCBSA High Performance Network - Tiered
  • Blue Shield NE NY PPO 6000 Series
  • CDPHP PPO National
  • Emblem Health GHI CBP
  • Emblem Health HIP Prime HMO
  • Emblem Select Care Small Group
  • EmblemHealth Millennium HMO
  • EmblemHealth Select Care
  • Empire BCBS Blue Access Employer Sponsored
  • Empire BCBS Blue Priority NY
  • Empire BCBS Connection Employer-Sponsored
  • Empire BCBS National Blue High Performance Network HPN
  • Empire BCBS PPO
  • Empire Connection Blue HPN
  • Empire Hospital
  • Empire Hospital/Medical (Trad)
  • Empire Individual Marketplace NYS QHP
  • Excellus BCBS Bassett Preferred
  • Excellus BCBS BluePPO HSA
  • Fidelis Care Qualified Health Plans
  • Fidelis Individual Marketplace NYS QHP
  • Humana / ChoiceCare Network PPO
  • Humana/ChoiceCare+ Network PPO
  • MagnaCare PPO
  • Medica Choice With UHC
  • MVP Health Plan EPO/PPO
  • NYS Provider & Health Emblem Individual Marketplace QHP
  • NYS Provider & Health EmblemHealth Essential Plan
  • NYS Provider & Health Oscar EPO NY
  • Oscar EPO NY
  • Highmark BCBS Blue High Performance Network
  • Connecticare Passage
  • Connecticare Flex Connecticut
  • Highmark BCBS Community Blue Flex PPO
  • Aetna AWH NJ Choice POS II MultiTier
  • Aetna AWH NJ Choice POS II MultiTier - Standard Savings
  • Highmark BCBS my Blue Access EPO
  • Aetna Savings Plus of New Jersey Choice POS II
  • EmblemHealth Gold D
  • Empire BCBS HealthPlus - Indiv MrktPlc QHP
  • Highmark BCBS PPO
  • Excellus BCBS ExchangeBlue
  • Fidelis Care All
  • Oscar NJ Exchange
View more

HOSPITAL AFFILIATIONS

SIMILAR PROVIDERS

Data Transparency and Trust: Understanding WebMD Doctor Listings and Reviews

We know that finding the right doctor or provider is important to your health. That’s why we want to ensure you have confidence in the provider profiles and listings you see on WebMD Care. Our provider data is sourced from the physicians themselves as well as publicly available databases. Any doctor or provider who claims their profile by verifying themselves can update their information and provide additional data on their specialties, education, accepted insurances, conditions they treat, and procedures they perform.

All the physician and provider reviews on WebMD Care are provided by users just like you. Knowing these reviews provide insight into how other patients feel about a doctor, we maintain internal policies and protocols to ensure the quality and accuracy of all reviews. Providers are not able to remove or modify reviews on their own. Reviews can only be removed after an internal review by our customer service team.

We value your input and encourage you to reach out to our support team if you encounter any issues.